- Dessert
- Easter
- Food for a Crowd
- Recipes
MozieMarch 2, 2024
Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe
This post may contain affiliate links, which means we’ll receive a commission if you purchase through our link, at no extra cost to you. See our disclosure here.
If you’ve had the luxury of trying banana pudding or pastries from the famous New York Bakery, Magnolia Bakery, you understand the obsession. Their banana pudding flies off the self everyday and is one of the reasons people flock to their store.
But what if we told you, you don’t have to fly all the way to New York to enjoy Magnolia bakeries world famous banana pudding…. You can enjoy it right in your own kitchen!!
We are sharing a banana pudding inspired by magnolia bakeries deliciously whipped, creamy banana pudding with swirls of pudding, fresh bananas, Nilla wafers and cake crumbles. It is a decadent treat that seems to hit the spot no matter the season.
New York Style Banana Pudding
(Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding)
What you need for New York Style Banana Pudding:
- Condensed Milk: Makes the pudding thick and extra creamy!! Normally you would make intent pudding with milk, but the condensed milk really gives a delicious texture and flavor.
- Jello Instant Vanilla Pudding: You want to make sure you use the instant vanilla pudding for this recipe! It has a super quick setting time which makes it super easy work with.
- Heavy Whipping Cream: Used to make homemade whipping cream, which will then be folded into the pudding to make it light and fluffy. We also recommend making a little extra for topping!
- Ripe Bananas: You want to make sure your banana are ripe, but not very brown. The bananas shouldn’t be green because they will be to tart and won’t be as yummy as the sweeter ripe bananas.
- Nilla Wafers Cookies: Vanilla wafer cookies are a crunchy vanilla cookie that becomes soft once it sets with the pudding. It adds a nice texture and flavor to the pudding.
- Boxed Yellow Cake Mix: Yellow cake mix has a delicious buttery flavor to it. We added a swirl of cake crumbles to add a yummy flavor and more texture to the pudding. When everything is added together, it is seriously to-die-for!!
- Eggs and Vegetable Oil: Just needed if you are using a boxed yellow cake mix.
Direction Snapshot:
- Make boxed cake mix.
- Make pudding and set in fridge.
- Make whipped cream.
- Layer banana pudding.
- Refrigerate and wait. 🙂
- Scoop out serving portions and enjoy!
How to Layer the Banana Pudding
Repeat these 4 layers two or three times until your trifle pan is full!
First Layer
Second Layer
Third Layer
Fourth Layer
Start with a layer of vanilla pudding.
Crumble cake on top of the pudding.
Next add a layer sliced bananas on top of the cake.
Lastly, add a single layer of Nilla wafers to cover the surface. Repeat all layers until the trifle is full.
How long do you have to refrigerate banana pudding?
We recommend a minimum of 4 hours but its best if you let it sit overnight.
Which is better: Homemade or Magnolia Bakery?
Now that we can say we have tried both bakery and homemade versions of this banana pudding, we have to say homemade is better! Even though you will never be able to beat the experience of being in New York and ordering from the Magnolia Bakery, there are a couple of reasons we prefer homemade.
The first reason is because it seems to taste more fresh.
Secondly, we love our addition of vanilla cake crumble to the original recipe!
New York Style Banana Pudding (Magnolia Bakery Banana Pudding)
5 Stars4 Stars3 Stars2 Stars1 Star
No reviews
A banana pudding inspired by magnolia bakeries deliciously whipped, creamy banana pudding with swirls of pudding, fresh bananas, Nilla wafers and cake crumbles.
Ingredients
Scale
1 14 oz can of condensed milk
1 1/2 cup cold water
1 5 oz package Jello instant pudding mix
4 cups heavy cream (1 cup for topping)
1 11 oz box vanilla wafer cookies
5 ripe bananas, chopped
1 box yellow cake mix
3 eggs (for cake)
1/3 cup oil (for cake)
Instructions
- Make cake mix according to package. After removing from oven, place on wire cooling racks to cool completely (about 1 hour). Once cooled, slice into cubes.
- While cakes are baking, make pudding. In an electric mixer, whisk condensed milk and water until combined. Pour in pudding mix and whisk until pudding is smooth. Pour into a container, seal with lid and leave in fridge for 1-2 hours or overnight.
- After pudding is set, make whipped cream. In a stand mixer on medium high speed, whisk heavy cream until it starts to thicken into cool whip. Make sure not to over whip. You want stiff peaks (when you pull out the whisk, the whipped cream will stand up straight). Remove 1 cup of whipped cream for topping.
- Fold pudding into whipped cream until evenly incorporated.
- Assemble the pudding in a trifle dish. First spread a layer of pudding. Next, crumble cake cubes over pudding. Then add a layer of bananas, then Nilla wafers. Top with another layer of pudding and repeat until trifle is filled.
- Top with extra whipped cream, cake and Nilla wafer crumbles and banana slices.
- Scoop and serve.
- Author: Mozie
Want more dessert ideas? Check these articles out:
- Biscoff White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookies
- The Best Lucky Charms Rice Krispie Cereal Treats
- Salted Chocolate Pecan Dessert Bars
7 Shares
banana puddingdessertsfood for crowdspring recipes
Leave a comment
